Finding something worth knowing…

Art

Eight lines on the moment nature closes the season and says no

In one compressed stanza, Emily Dickinson pictures nature as a craftsman who has used up her colours. Any flower missing this year might be repaid next summer, if another summer comes. But when nature finally refuses, her no is absolute and cancels every chance that remains.

The poem is a single block of eight short lines, and its vocabulary is oddly financial and legal. Nature has fulfilled her dyes, as though finishing a contract to colour the world. Flowers that fail to appear might be made good, reimbursed, by her crescent, the waxing phase of later summers. That promise comes with a hedge, though: only if there are other summers to come.

The final two lines deliver the verdict. Nature's imposing negative, Dickinson writes, nulls opportunity. The word negative can be read as a refusal, but also as the shadow side of all that abundance, the frost or ending that no amount of future growth can undo. The poem never mentions death, yet the logic points there: seasons can compensate for one another only as long as the cycle continues.

It shows the two subjects that dominate her work, the natural world and mortality, folded into each other. It also shows the style that makes her poems feel modern: terse, pointed lines, very little description, and rhymes that sit slightly off, like come and days, or be and opportunity. The Poetry Foundation says she built an elliptical language for things that were possible but not yet realised, and here the unrealised flower is the whole subject.

Her feel for plants and landscape had formal roots. During seven years at Amherst Academy she studied botany and geology alongside Latin, history and arithmetic. Illness interrupted her schooling; in 1845 and 1846 she was enrolled for only eleven weeks, yet she told a friend she thought it a very fine school.

Source: Nature can do no more

Related

More in Art · All topics