Why did a critically panned Eddie Murphy comedy become a cult favorite for some?

Entertainment · Published 3 October 2026 Swipe more like this →

In short: Released in 2007, Norbit was a box office hit that simultaneously earned three Golden Raspberry Awards and a reputation for being hideously offensive. Yet, despite the vitriol from critics and accusations of perpetuating harmful stereotypes, the film remains a point of genuine affection for its star, Eddie Murphy.

Directed by Brian Robbins, Norbit features Eddie Murphy in multiple roles, including the titular character and his abusive wife, Rasputia. The film’s production relied heavily on complex prosthetics and bodysuits created by Rick Baker, who noted that Murphy spent significant time in the makeup chair without complaint. While the technical achievement earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Makeup, the narrative—which Murphy developed after watching online videos of large women fighting smaller men—drew sharp condemnation. Critics and activists labeled the film a 'minstrel show' and a 'hideous stew of bigoted humor,' with many arguing it relied on cruel stereotypes.

The timing of the release proved particularly controversial, as it hit theaters during the 2007 Oscar voting season. Some observers believe the backlash against Norbit cost Murphy the Best Supporting Actor award for his performance in Dreamgirls, which ultimately went to Alan Arkin. Despite the negative consensus on sites like Rotten Tomatoes, where it holds a 9% approval rating, the film was a commercial success, grossing $159 million worldwide against a $60 million budget. Director Brian Robbins defended the project, arguing that critics were not the intended audience and praising Murphy’s ability to portray three distinct characters.

The film’s legacy has taken unexpected turns. In 2025, Murphy reaffirmed his love for the project, stating that he still finds it funny. Furthermore, the film gained an unusual cultural afterlife when a 2007 interview revealed that Beach Boys musician Brian Wilson considered it his favorite movie. This claim later evolved into an internet meme, with fans dedicating reviews to Wilson. Whether viewed as a crude misfire or a misunderstood comedic feat, Norbit remains a polarizing artifact in Murphy’s career, illustrating the deep divide between industry reception, critical standards, and audience sentiment.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

• Why a box-office smash was called the worst megahit of all time
• Why a misunderstood 1995 vampire comedy became an unlikely cult classic decades later
• How Eddie Murphy transformed a classic into a 1996 box-office juggernaut
• Why Eddie Murphy’s 1997 action thriller Metro remains a polarizing Hollywood experiment
• Why a 1998 Satirical Comedy Became One of Eddie Murphy's Most Regretted Projects
• How a critically panned animated film became an unlikely, multi-sequel franchise success story
• How a high-stakes action thriller turned an airplane cabin into a claustrophobic puzzle box
• How a factory worker’s silent protest became a defining moment in American labor cinema
• A teenage outsider in a remote Icelandic village dreams of a tropical escape
• Why did one of Hollywood's most respected directors create a film critics universally loathed?
• Can a woman save Christmas when the heir to the North Pole flees?
• How a chaotic, scriptless production became a surprise 1960 box office hit

More in Films · More in Entertainment · Latest · A–Z · All topics