A Danish-born banker became the father of modern historical method
In short: Barthold Georg Niebuhr, born in Copenhagen in 1776, never had a formal start in history. He became a banker and diplomat first. Yet he reshaped how historians treat their sources, and nearly every serious historian since owes him a debt. His method was simple in principle: question every source, strip away what cannot be trusted, and rebuild the facts underneath.
Niebuhr was the only son of Carsten Niebuhr, a Danish explorer of German descent. His early education came largely from his father, and by his teens he was a capable classical scholar reading several languages. He studied law and philosophy at the University of Kiel, but his path into scholarship was far from direct. On his father's advice he spent time in England and Scotland, and he later said that living among English civic life helped him understand the societies of antiquity. He then entered state service, working as a secretary to a Danish minister of finance and later directing a national bank.
Niebuhr moved to Prussia in 1806 for a similar post. He was capable with money, but his sensitive temperament made him difficult in politics, and he withdrew from public office. In 1810 he became royal historiographer and began lecturing at the newly founded University of Berlin. These lectures on Roman history formed the basis of his three-volume History of Rome, published between 1811 and 1832. The first volumes attracted little notice at the time, because political events in Europe were absorbing attention.
The lasting value of Niebuhr's work lies less in his conclusions than in his method. Some of his theories were extravagant and some of his conclusions were mistaken. What he did was develop a disciplined scepticism toward ancient texts, which Goethe called constructive scepticism. Niebuhr showed how to analyse the layers within a source, especially poetic and mythical traditions, and how to set aside material that could not be relied on. The historical facts could then be reconstructed from what remained.
Niebuhr's later career included diplomatic service as Prussian ambassador to the Vatican from 1816, and he retired to Bonn in 1823. He also found and published fragments of classical authors, including Cicero and Livy, and deciphered a palimpsest containing work by the fifth-century Roman poet Flavius Merobaudes. He died in Bonn in 1831. His significance is that he gave historians a rigorous way of testing evidence, a foundation on which the great period of German historical scholarship was built.
Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.
Sources
- Summary by Intellect · source: Barthold Georg Niebuhr | Romanticism, Prussian Reforms, Enlightenment | Britannica
- Also: Barthold Georg Niebuhr
To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/history-barthold-georg-niebuhr.
How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.
General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.
Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?
Related
More in Ancient rome · More in History · Latest · A–Z · All topics