A famous phrase began as a warning, not a boast
In short: Long before it became a slogan in American politics, the phrase city upon a hill was a warning. In 1630, John Winthrop told his fellow colonists that the whole world would be watching, and that breaking their covenant with God would make them an object of scorn. Presidents later reused the image, but its original meaning was very different from the boast it became.
John Winthrop led the Massachusetts Bay Colony as its first governor and stood at the centre of the Puritan settlement of New England. Born in 1588 in England, he came from the gentry, a class that rose to dominate English society between 1540 and 1640. He studied law, held a government post, and only later became intensely religious, convinced he had been chosen for salvation. In 1630, while sailing west on the Arbella, he wrote a lay sermon titled A Modell of Christian Charity. In it he described the colonists as bound by covenant to God and to one another, called to build a city on a hill in New England while the whole world looked on. His point was a warning: if they betrayed God, they would be mocked and their failure would be told across the world.
Winthrop was chosen governor twelve times between 1631 and 1648, and he spent his later years in the wilderness as a father figure to the settlers. His rule was not without strain. Dissenters challenged his system through the 1630s, freemen pressed for an elected assembly, and Roger Williams criticised the link between church and state. Winthrop found such challenges hard to accept, and he saw the move of colonists to Connecticut as a personal rejection. The sermon itself was largely overlooked for nearly two centuries, until a historical society in Massachusetts printed it in 1839.
Later generations gave the phrase a much grander role. Cold War era historians and politicians treated the sermon as the founding text of American exceptionalism, a reading the historian Dan T. Rogers has argued is mistaken, since the first Puritans did not see a great national destiny ahead. Presidents John F. Kennedy and Ronald Reagan both invoked the image, while Mario Cuomo answered it with the contrast of A Tale of Two Cities. Reading the original sermon beside these later uses shows how the same words can serve as a warning or as a boast, depending on who speaks and when.
Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.
Sources
- Summary by Intellect · source: John Winthrop | Significance, Beliefs, City upon a Hill | Britannica
- Also: City upon a Hill
To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/history-city-upon-a-hill.
How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.
General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.
Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?
Related
More in History · Latest · A–Z · All topics