Finding something worth knowing…

History

Christian apologetics has nothing to do with saying sorry

In ancient Greek, an apologia was a courtroom defence, the kind Socrates mounted against charges of corrupting the young. Early Christians borrowed the form to answer emperors and critics. Around 125 CE Quadratus of Athens addressed one to Hadrian, and the tradition runs through Aquinas and Pascal to C. S. Lewis.

The word comes from apologeomai, to speak in return or defend oneself. Christians trace their mandate to 1 Peter, which urges believers to be ready to explain their hope, gently and respectfully, to anyone who asks. Paul's speech on Mars Hill in Acts is often read as an early example, and Jewish writers such as Philo and Josephus had already produced defences of their own faith for Greek-speaking audiences.

Second-century Christians were a small, suspect minority competing with Judaism and many cults. Their apologists aimed at emperors, officials and curious outsiders, arguing that Christianity was rational and that believers were law-abiding subjects who honoured the emperor but could not swear oaths treating him as divine. Only a fragment of Quadratus survives, quoted by Eusebius. The philosopher Celsus launched a sweeping attack around 175 CE in The True Word, painting Christians as useless to society. Decades after Celsus died, Origen answered point by point in Contra Celsum, writing as a Platonist and giving his faith intellectual standing. Rather than reject Greek philosophy, these writers tried to show how Christianity fitted with it, and their texts also reassured doubting believers inside the church.

Medieval thinkers sharpened the arguments. Anselm of Canterbury proposed the ontological argument in his Proslogion; Thomas Aquinas laid out five ways to demonstrate God's existence and criticised Anselm's reasoning so effectively that it lost favour until René Descartes revived it. In the 17th century Blaise Pascal sketched a strategy in his Pensées: first show religion is not contrary to reason, then make it respected, then lovable, and only then prove it true.

Modern apologetics splinters by tradition. William Paley popularised the watchmaker analogy in the 19th century, and C. S. Lewis spread the argument now called Lewis's trilemma. Gordon Clark and Cornelius Van Til founded presuppositionalism, favoured in Calvinist circles, while Seraphim Rose became perhaps the best-known English-speaking Orthodox apologist. Scholars still debate whether apologetics is a distinct literary genre or simply a tone and purpose of writing.

Source: Christian apologetics

Related

More in History · All topics