Why did the 17th-century audience hate the plays we now consider absolute masterpieces?

Ideas & Philosophy · Published 3 October 2026 Swipe more like this →

In short: John Webster, a contemporary of Shakespeare, wrote tragedies so dark and intellectually complex that they baffled his original working-class audiences. Today, his unsparing vision of human nature is celebrated as a pinnacle of Jacobean drama, with critics noting that his bleak, violent world resonates deeply with modern sensibilities.

John Webster (c. 1578–c. 1632) remains an elusive figure, with his life obscured by a lack of definitive records. Likely born in London to a carriage maker, he attended the Merchant Taylors' School and may have studied at the Middle Temple. While he collaborated on numerous plays with figures like Thomas Dekker, Thomas Middleton, and William Rowley, his enduring reputation rests on two tragedies: The White Devil and The Duchess of Malfi.

The reception of his work was historically polarized. The White Devil, staged at the open-air Red Bull Theatre in 1612, was a failure; its intellectual density and complex structure were ill-suited for a working-class crowd seeking simple escapism. Conversely, The Duchess of Malfi, performed around 1614 at the indoor Blackfriars Theatre, found a more receptive, educated audience. This shift in venue allowed for a more controlled environment, featuring artificial lighting and musical interludes that perhaps helped the audience process the play's rapid, often jarring, narrative pacing.

Webster’s work is defined by a uniquely grim perspective. T.S. Eliot famously characterized his ability to see the "skull beneath the skin," a phrase that captures the playwright's obsession with mortality and human corruption. Unlike many of his peers, Webster centered his tragedies on virtuous women, such as the Duchess, who face their destruction with Stoic courage. While 18th and 19th-century critics largely dismissed his plays as excessive, the 20th century saw a revival of interest. Analysts suggest that the horrors of modern warfare made Webster’s themes of uncontrollable events and desperate, violent survival feel strikingly relevant once again.

Today, Webster’s influence permeates literature and film, from P.D. James’s detective fiction to appearances in popular media like Boardwalk Empire. His plays continue to be staged, serving as a testament to the enduring power of his "horrific vision of humanity." Whether through his intricate characterizations or his unflinching portrayal of the darkness within, Webster remains a foundational, if unsettling, voice in English literature.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

• A secret marriage leads to a nightmare of revenge in this Jacobean stage masterpiece
• Shakespeare’s plays were not solitary masterpieces but collaborative products of a shifting theatrical landscape.
• John Fletcher: The Playwright Who Defined the Jacobean Stage Beyond Shakespeare
• A deadly New York riot erupted over how to perform Shakespeare
• The terrifying legend of the play that allegedly summoned real devils
• How a failed lawyer became one of Norway's four literary giants
• Salinas Valley novels that won a Nobel—and death threats
• Dean Swift coined Vanessa and made satire feel surgical
• How a radical poet’s ten-year prison sentence for two joints changed American constitutional law.
• Bahia’s storyteller went from banned books to Academy chair
• Why the Chief Justice of the United States compares his role to a baseball umpire
• Buenos Aires librarian who rebuilt fiction with labyrinths

More in Writers · More in Ideas & Philosophy · Latest · A–Z · All topics