A famous argument about Jesus depends on a premise many scholars reject

A famous argument about Jesus depends on a premise many scholars reject
Image: Intellect (generated)

In short: C. S. Lewis argued that Jesus could only have been a liar, a lunatic, or God. Known as Lewis's trilemma, the argument has shaped Christian apologetics for decades, yet critics say it rests on a claim about Jesus that most biblical scholars do not accept. Here is how the argument works and why people still debate it.

Lewis's trilemma is an apologetic argument, a case made to defend a religious belief. It offers three options, each hard to accept: that Jesus was evil, mad, or divine. Lewis popularised it through radio talks he gave for the BBC, later gathered into his book Mere Christianity, and it is often summarised as "Lunatic, Liar, or Lord" or "Mad, Bad, or God." Lewis was an Oxford medieval literature scholar and a former atheist. The argument is older than Lewis: a form of it appeared in 1846 in lectures by the American preacher Mark Hopkins.

The writer G. K. Chesterton used something close to it in The Everlasting Man in 1925, a book Lewis later named among the most influential he had read. Later users included the biblical scholar Bruce Metzger and the former US president Ronald Reagan, who used it in a 1978 written reply to a Methodist minister. Its central premise is that Jesus claimed to be God. Lewis pointed to claims such as having authority to forgive sins and intending to return to judge the world.

Critics respond that this premise is the weakest point. The biblical scholar Bart Ehrman has argued that it is historically inaccurate that Jesus called himself God, and the Anglican bishop John A. T. Robinson questioned whether Jesus claimed to be the Son of God at all. John Hick, writing in 1993, said that developments in New Testament studies had undermined the argument. A second criticism is logical: the trilemma offers only three options, and critics say the list is incomplete. Craig Evans suggested that Jesus might have been Israel's messiah, a great prophet, or someone the New Testament portrays inaccurately.

Paul Little expanded the list to four by adding legend, and Peter Kreeft and Ronald Tacelli have proposed a fifth, that Jesus was a guru who regarded everything as divine. Lewis himself argued in a 1950 essay that the Gospels are not legends, on literary grounds. Whether that answer settles the question remains contested among believers, sceptics and historians alike. The argument is a useful case study in how a famous line of reasoning can outlast the evidence it depends on, and whichever side you take, wording and assumptions shape how convincing it feels.

Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.

Sources

To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/ideas-lewis-s-trilemma.

How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

Finding something worth knowing…