Finding something worth knowing…

Society

Nonmarital breakups can hurt as much as formal divorce

A breakup ends a romantic relationship; slang says one partner “dumped” the other when initiation is one-sided. The label less often covers marital splits. Psychotherapist Susie Orbach argued in 1992 that ending dating or cohabiting ties can equal or exceed divorce pain because those bonds lack divorce’s ritual recognition.

For married couples the ending is usually called separation or divorce, and an engaged pair who split has a broken engagement. Breakups need not be romantic: friendships also dissolve, usually because nobody kept them up. Drawing on Donald Winnicott, Kamiar-K. Rueckert treats the capacity to be alone as a sign of emotional maturity; a child who has felt secure closeness with early caregivers can build autonomy, while one who never absorbed that protection tends to dread separation.

Many models describe dissolution as a series of stages. Mark Knapp's relational development model has a coming-together phase and a coming-apart phase. Coming apart starts with differentiating, when partners notice differences that feel non-negotiable, then circumscribing, as they set boundaries and live more separately. Stagnation follows, when they stay together for reasons such as children rather than desire, then avoidance, and finally termination. Other schemes include L. Lee's five stages and Steve Duck's six-stage cycle, and Gottman and Levenson's 1994 cascade model links four negative nonverbal behaviours to breakdown.

In 1976 the sociologist Diane Vaughan proposed uncoupling theory, built around a turning point when someone realises everything has gone dead inside, followed by a period, sometimes years, in which that partner holds on while privately knowing the end is coming. She saw the process as lopsided: the initiator has already mourned and rehearsed life alone, while the other must catch up by recasting the partner and the relationship negatively. Uncoupling is finished, she argued, once neither person draws identity mainly from being a couple.

The therapist Katherine Woodward Thomas coined conscious uncoupling in 2009, and Gwyneth Paltrow made it famous describing her split from Chris Martin.

Source: Breakup

Related

More in Society · All topics