Why some accents are seen as 'correct' while others are not

Why some accents are seen as 'correct' while others are not
Image: Intellect (generated)

In short: Ask who decides what counts as correct speech and you find something surprising: linguists broadly agree that no variety of a language is inherently better than another. Yet a dialect's standing depends on who speaks it. Language carries social status, and that status can shape how people speak, how they are treated, and even whether a variety is called a language or a dialect.

Prestige, in sociolinguistics, is the regard a speech community gives to a language or dialect compared with others. Prestige varieties are often seen as the most correct or superior form, and frequently they are the standard language promoted by authorities. Yet prestige does not come from grammar. Linguists hold that every variety is systematic and rule governed, and that when varieties are assessed on purely linguistic grounds, all have equal merit. Their status comes from the social standing of the people who speak them. Latin, for example, was admired largely because of the churchmen, lawyers and scholars who used it, and William Jones's praise of Sanskrit in the 18th century shows how prestige can shape even claims about a language's antiquity and beauty.

Prestige also works in less obvious ways. Overt prestige attaches to standard, formal language and signals power and status. Covert prestige attaches to vernacular speech and signals solidarity and group identity. William Labov's 1966 study of New York department stores showed how r-pronunciation tracked social class, with employees at the high-end store pronouncing it most often. Labov also found hypercorrection, where lower-class speakers added r to words that never had one, reflecting their awareness of its prestige. Studies of fraternity men and of Korean-American students using African American Vernacular English suggest that non-standard forms can also carry value within particular groups.

Education and media reinforce these hierarchies. Walt Wolfram notes that teachers often correct African American Vernacular English, which can subordinate students and their families, and that children's films often give standard accents to protagonists and other accents to minor or antagonist characters. Researchers have also observed patterns by gender: in several societies, women tend to use prestige forms more than men, with explanations ranging from social conformity to associations between lower-class women and sexual immorality.

Contact between languages reflects power as well. When languages have equal standing they can share features, as Old English and Old Norse did. When one has more power, as in many colonial settings, the weaker language often lends sounds while the stronger supplies vocabulary and grammar, and English borrowed many words from French during periods of French prestige. Scholars therefore treat prestige as a key to understanding variation, language change and even why two closely related speech forms are labelled languages in one place and dialects in another.

Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.

Sources

To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/society-prestige-sociolinguistics.

How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

Finding something worth knowing…