Can a simple geometric question have three different, equally valid mathematical answers?
In short: In 1889, Joseph Bertrand proposed a simple puzzle: what is the probability that a random chord in a circle is longer than the side of an inscribed equilateral triangle? Depending on how you define random, you get three different answers. This paradox exposes a fundamental ambiguity in probability theory.
The Bertrand paradox arises when applying the principle of indifference—the idea that we should assign equal probabilities to all possibilities—to infinite domains. Bertrand demonstrated this by offering three distinct methods for selecting a 'random' chord, each appearing logically sound yet yielding a different result. The 'random endpoints' method, which selects two points on the circumference, results in a probability of 1/3. The 'random radial point' method, which chooses a point on a radius to define a perpendicular chord, yields 1/2. Finally, the 'random midpoint' method, which selects a point anywhere within the circle to serve as the chord's center, produces 1/4.
These discrepancies occur because the methods assign different weights to the set of all possible chords. For instance, the midpoint method treats the center of the circle as the midpoint for every diameter, while the radial method treats diameters differently than other chords. Because the problem does not specify the physical mechanism for selecting the chord, the term 'at random' remains ill-defined. Without a specified selection process, the principle of indifference fails to provide a unique, objective solution.
In 1973, Edwin Jaynes attempted to resolve the paradox by invoking 'maximum ignorance.' He argued that a well-posed problem should be indifferent to the size and position of the circle, requiring scale and translation invariance. Jaynes concluded that the radial method was the only one satisfying these criteria. However, later analysis by Alon Drory in 2015 challenged this, demonstrating that each of Bertrand's original solutions can be derived using specific invariance properties, provided one assumes a different underlying physical experiment. Ultimately, the paradox serves as a reminder that probability is not just a mathematical abstraction but is deeply tied to the specific, often hidden, assumptions we make about how a process unfolds.
The debate highlights how our intuition regarding randomness is often context-dependent. Whether you are throwing straws, spinning a device, or tracking a fly landing on molasses, the physical constraints of your experiment dictate the mathematical outcome. Bertrand's paradox remains a cornerstone in the philosophy of probability, illustrating that what we call 'random' is frequently a reflection of the procedure we choose to observe it.
Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.
Sources
- Summary by Intellect · source: Bertrand paradox (probability)
To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/technology-bertrand-paradox-probability.
How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.
General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.
Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?
Related
More in Inventions · More in Technology · Latest · A–Z · All topics