Is our definition of a species actually holding back science?

Space · Published 27 October 2026 Swipe more like this →

In short: Biology relies on the concept of species as a fundamental building block, but what if this classification is an obstacle? Philosopher Carol Cleland suggests that by clinging to traditional categories, we may be preventing ourselves from discovering deeper universal laws about life in the cosmos.

Carol Cleland, a philosopher of science and astrobiology expert, argues that the current biological framework might be insufficient for future discovery. Her work explores how our definitions of 'life' and 'species' are often rooted in Earth-centric observations. This creates a potential bottleneck: if we only look for life that fits into existing taxonomic buckets, we may overlook forms of existence that operate under fundamentally different principles.

Cleland’s research focuses on the nature of scientific inquiry and how we recognize life that differs from anything found on our planet. She has explored concepts such as the 'shadow biosphere'—a term she coined to describe the possibility of life existing on Earth that is distinct from known biological lineages. By questioning these categories, she aims to move toward a more universal theory of life that isn't limited by current human models.

The implications are significant for astrobiology and our search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI). If we want to understand the universe, Cleland suggests we need new categories before we can identify deeper laws. Her work emphasizes the role of anomalies in scientific discovery, suggesting that recognizing what doesn't fit our current models is often the first step toward a major breakthrough in understanding reality.

Cleland holds a PhD from Brown University and has collaborated with NASA’s Astrobiology Institute. Her interdisciplinary approach combines philosophy, logic, and metaphysics to examine how different scientific disciplines resolve anomalies. By deconstructing the 'natural kinds' of biology, she seeks to provide a framework that can accommodate life as we don't yet know it.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

• Biologists cannot agree on what a species is, and count over two dozen definitions
• We are still searching for the true number of species on Earth
• Why biology resists being shoved into neat little boxes
• Is the ancient science of zoology fragmenting into isolated pieces?
• Why the variety of life is more than just a list of species
• Australia's prehistoric past was a landscape of literal monsters
• Why modern spacecraft choose long, winding paths to reach the Moon instead of direct.
• The Atlantic's conveyor belt is slowing, threatening a global climate tipping point
• Why a modern conspiracy theory rejects 2,000 years of geometry
• Is a perfectly good God mathematically improbable?
• Why some people are mosquito magnets (it’s not your blood)
• The West Coast faces a 'doublet' threat from two connected faults

More in Space · Latest · A–Z · All topics