Can a sequel survive when its predecessor was a lightning-in-a-bottle comedic success?

Entertainment · Published 3 October 2026 Swipe more like this →

In short: Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2 returns to Swallow Falls, where the rogue food-making machine has evolved to create sentient food-animal hybrids. While the film was a financial hit, critics remained divided on whether this second helping captured the original's unique charm or simply piled on chaotic, sugary noise.

Released in 2013, the sequel follows inventor Flint Lockwood as he is recruited by his childhood idol, Chester V, to clean up the island of Swallow Falls. The island, previously devastated by a food storm, has been overrun by 'foodimals'—living, sentient creatures made of sustenance. The plot hinges on a corporate conspiracy: Chester V’s company, Live Corp, aims to capture these creatures to process them into food bars. The revelation that 'Live' is 'evil' spelled backward sets the stage for a showdown between Flint and his former hero.

The film’s production saw significant changes, with directors Cody Cameron and Kris Pearn taking the helm from the original’s Phil Lord and Chris Miller. The voice cast saw the return of Bill Hader and Anna Faris, while Terry Crews stepped in to replace Mr. T as the athletic police officer Earl Devereaux. Despite the high-energy premise and the introduction of imaginative creatures like the Cheespider and Barry the strawberry, the film faced a mixed critical reception. It holds a 71% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with many reviewers noting that while it offers dazzling visuals, it lacks the intellectual depth and narrative nimbleness of the 2009 original.

Commercially, the film was a success, grossing $274.3 million worldwide against a $78 million budget. It spawned various tie-ins, including a Nintendo game and a mobile app, alongside a series of animated shorts. Whether the film is viewed as a 'sugary treat' or a 'stale' imitation often depends on the viewer's appetite for manic, pun-heavy humor. While some critics praised its zany, colorful world-building as a potential cult classic for a new generation, others felt the relentless pacing and gags-on-gags approach eventually overwhelmed the story’s heart.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

• How a critically panned 2010 animated film spawned an unlikely seven-sequel franchise
• How a comedy sequel turned a bachelor party nightmare into a global box office hit
• Can a corporate consultant save a small town by pivoting to tapioca pudding?
• A sequel to a cult classic that struggled to find its own identity
• Can a 1948 Cary Grant classic survive a 2007 slapstick comedy remake?
• The Russian mutant who became a living weapon to save the world from disease.
• Why a giant red dog joined a traveling animal show in 2004
• The Simpsons character who became the ultimate avatar for internet fan culture
• The Complex and Chaotic Family Tree of Springfield's Most Famous Hillbilly, Cletus Spuckler
• The moral anchor of Gotham: a man who chose a vigilante over the law.
• Clayface is not one villain, but a shifting legacy of tragedy and science
• Count Dooku was a disillusioned Jedi Master who became a powerful Sith Lord

More in Animated series & cartoons · More in Entertainment · Latest · A–Z · All topics