The location of a New Testament town is still debated by archaeologists

The location of a New Testament town is still debated by archaeologists
Image: Intellect (generated)

In short: Bethsaida appears in the New Testament as the home town of several apostles, yet modern researchers have not agreed on where it stood. Three sites by the Sea of Galilee remain candidates, and each has its supporters. Recent digs have shifted the balance, but the question is still open.

Bethsaida is mentioned in the New Testament, where John 1:44 names it as the home town of Peter, Andrew and Philip. Later, the ruler Philip the Tetrarch raised the village to the status of a polis and renamed it Julias, in honour of Livia, the wife of Augustus. Ancient writers disagree about its position. Pliny the Elder placed it on the far side of the lake, while the historian Josephus put it in Lower Gaulanitis, a district that is now part of the Golan Heights.

Since the nineteenth century, scholars have proposed three candidate sites. El-Araj lies where the upper Jordan River flows into the lake. Et-Tell sits on the east bank of the Jordan and is promoted by a team led by Rami Arav. El-Mesydiah is a third option, generally considered the least likely. Et-Tell has yielded remains from the Iron Age, and its city was destroyed between 734 and 732 BCE. Fishing gear found there suggests that much of its later economy depended on the lake. A problem is that et-Tell lies about 2 km from the shore, an odd spot for a fishing village. Researchers have offered explanations, including tectonic uplift, a falling water level and sediment extending the Jordan delta.

Recent work has drawn attention to el-Araj. In 2017, archaeologists reported a Roman bathhouse there, lying beneath a Byzantine layer separated by a gap in occupation during the mid-third to mid-fourth centuries. In 2019, excavators described a Byzantine church that some believe was built over the house of the brothers Peter and Andrew, and in 2022 they uncovered a mosaic inscription that calls on St. Peter. The excavation co-leader, Professor R. Steven Notley, argued that these finds make el-Araj the leading candidate. Other scholars remain unconvinced, and the evidence is still being weighed.

The debate also turns on how to read the gospel texts. Some scholars argue that the New Testament references all point to one town, Bethsaida Julias, while others think there were two places with the same name, which was common in the region. The abundance of fish along the shore made the name plausible in more than one spot. Because the sources are ancient, written at a distance and with imprecise geography, the question may never be settled to everyone's satisfaction. What is clear is that the search has produced real archaeology, and each new find reshapes the picture of the lakeshore in the first century.

Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.

Sources

To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/history-bethsaida.

How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.

General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.

Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?

Related

Finding something worth knowing…