The accidental entry in the Messier catalog that turned out to be a mistake
In short: Charles Messier is famous for his catalog of deep-sky objects, but one entry, Winnecke 4, stands out as a blunder. While hunting for a reported nebula in 1764, Messier found only a faint double star. It was not a nebula at all, yet it remains a permanent part of his legacy.
In 1764, the astronomer Charles Messier was searching the constellation Ursa Major for a nebula previously reported by Johannes Hevelius. When he failed to find any nebulosity, he cataloged a nearby pair of stars instead. Historians believe Hevelius had actually observed 74 and 75 Ursae Majoris, a pair of 5th to 6th magnitude stars that appear close enough to the naked eye to look like a single, fuzzy object. Messier, however, recorded a much fainter pair of 9th to 10th magnitude stars, now known as Winnecke 4 or Messier 40.
The inclusion of this object in Messier's catalog has long been criticized. Robert Burnham famously labeled it one of the few genuine errors in the collection, noting that Messier had documented a simple double star rather than the deep-sky phenomenon he was supposed to be tracking. The pair was later rediscovered in 1863 by Friedrich August Theodor Winnecke, who included it in his own catalog of double stars as number 4.
Modern astronomy has definitively settled the nature of Winnecke 4. While early observations noted a separation of 51.7 arcseconds in 1991, subsequent research by Brian Skiff in 2001 and Richard L. Nugent in 2002 confirmed it is merely an optical double—two stars that appear close from our perspective but are physically unrelated. Gaia satellite parallax measurements reveal the vast distance between them: the brighter star, HD 238107, sits at about 1,013 light-years, while its companion, HD 238108, is significantly closer at roughly 470 light-years. Interestingly, HD 238108 is itself a binary system, featuring an 18th-magnitude white dwarf companion located 5 arcseconds away, proving that even a cataloging mistake can lead to complex and fascinating stellar discoveries.
Opens the Intellect+ feed with this card first. Swipe up for the next one.
Sources
- Summary by Intellect · source: Winnecke 4
To cite this card, link to https://intellectplus.co.uk/app/science-winnecke-4.
How we source, check and correct cards: Editorial standards.
General information, not professional advice. Spotted an error? Flag the card or see corrections and complaints.
Intellect Plus is a visual educational discovery platform for exploring fascinating facts and ideas. Brain Food, Not Brain Rot. What is Intellect Plus?
Related
More in Scientific discoveries · More in Science · Latest · A–Z · All topics